Pages

Saturday, June 21, 2025

Deep Sea Sail

Tallships at sunset
Credit: peakpx.com

On Jstor I came across this article from the North American Review, Vol. 233, No. 4 (Apr., 1932), pages. 326-332, published by University of Northern Iowa. It is written by A.J. Villiers, a sailing Captain and a historian of tall ships in his time, here he laments of the state of the sailing fleet. It is a quite interesting history when he opens up the on how the tall ships demise came about, basically people just wrecked the industry.

s/v Royal Clipper
Credit: Cbuske46 (wikipedia)

There has been tall ships built later on but more like one off projects or small batches that I suppose must have been a learning curve for the builder as well. Furthermore, it seems there is no major R&D put in these designs so I think old plans has been used as basis without much thoughts put in terms of improvements except adding in propulsion and compliance with safety regulations. These ships have also been more for passenger tourism or sail training purposes rather than actually shipping cargo like it was in the old days. More recent examples are Royal Clipper launched in 2000 and Golden Horizon launched in 2017, both are based on old designs, the first on the flying "P" Liners Preussen (1902) and the latter on France II (1911). Alan Villiers would definitely be smiling seeing these ships in action.

s/v Golden Horizon
Credit: kveranka (marinetraffic)

The latest infamous incident to bring tall ships in the mainstream media was with the Mexican sailing ship, Cuauhtémoc, that collided with the New York Brooklyn bridge in 2025. Cuauhtémoc is the last of four sister ships built by the naval Celaya Shipyards of Bilbao, Spain, in 1982, all built to a design similar to the 1930 designs of the German firm Blohm & Voss, like Gorch Fock. She was delivered to the Mexican Navy in July 1982.

Cuauhtémoc under sail
Credit: Dublin Port

Japanese Kaiwo Maru (built 1989) at Steveston, British Columbia, Canada in 2017
Credit: Colin MacGregor Stevens (captainstevens.com)

Today sailing cargo ships are being designed anew with modern ideas, for example 100 years ago the Jarvis brace winches came about, and other ideas of improvements to manage the sails. Just as the tall ship industry was in it's heyday then there was no more development put in these ships as all focus was directed on the steam ships development.

s/y Black Pearl
Credit: Oceanco

Modern sailing yachts have been built with automation in mind to reduce crew for the rig as well as to reduce moving parts like ropes, blocks and stays. The Black Pearl is a good example of innovation and sustainability, she is able to cross the Atlantic on sail only all the while harvesting kinetic energy for her onboard electric consumers. I presume the price for the rig is so expensive that it is not worthwhile for commercial ventures or perhaps when more weight is added (say 5000tons of cargo) the sails and masts  won't hold the stress and break (?). One for the naval engineering boffins. Not to mention cost of spare sails and how to bend them on (at sea?) as well as the maintenance of the rigging motors needed with plc's and whatnot. Ascending the masts alone may not be everybody's cup of tea with heights of nearly 100m. 

Flettner rotors on a bulk carrier
Credit: Oldendorff

Sail assisted yacht A
Credit: superyachtfan.com

Still most recently it was reported on 20th June 2025 that the worlds largest sailing ship, Orient Express Corinthian has been launched by shipbuilder Chantiers de l’Atlantique in Saint-Nazaire, France. Her dimensions are at 220m long and with gross tonnage of 26,200gt. In 2023 hospitality provider Accor and shipbuilder Chantiers de l’Atlantique announced the build.

The shipbuilder’s in-house designed SolidSail wind sail system will utilise three 100m tall lightweight masts each of which will be rigged with 1500 sq.m. Solid Sail/AeolDrive rigid but foldable sails. The engine will be powered by liquefied natural gas (LNG). Wonder what Alan Villiers would say about this development?

Floating out of Orient Express Corinthian
Credit: marineindustrynews.com

Rendering of Orient Express Corinthian from 2023
Credit: Martin Darzacq

New designs, some with massive kites towing the vessels over the ocean, others are using old inventions refreshed, e.g. hybrid solutions like Flettner rotors (invented in ca 1920) combined with engines. In yachting they have developed sail assisted yachts combined with engines, like e.g. s/y A built in 2017 by Nobiskrug in Germany. The designers are still running wild with various concepts as depicted here in this article from 2020 by Yachting World, it also seems to be a trend of doing multihulled solutions, at least when going for speed.

Trimaran with futuristic wing sails
Credit: French designer Mathis Rühl (Yachting World)

Rendering of future
Credit: windschip.nl (LinkedIn)

The kite concept visualised

One surmises that what if they'd been continuing the development and shipping cargo by sail what would the advances be in todays world? Personally I would welcome the proposal to captain one of these modern sailing vessels over the oceans if I'd be offered the opportunity. Good examples of modern sailing ships carrying cargo is US based grain de sail that looks like any modern leisure yacht. They appear to carry small batches of coffee and cocoa from the Caribbean Islands to the USA. 

Grain De Sail cargo ship (graindesail-overseas.com)

There is also a number of French companies; Windcoop, that intend to operate larger cargo sailing ships in 2027 and Ariane group with their already launched hybrid design to carry rocket parts to S. America. Also see the Transoceanic Wind Transport with 2 ships in operation and another 6 coming in 2026. So, maybe the wind ships are having a renaissance after all or is the French Gov't repeating themselves in the same fashion as in the early 1900's? Alan Villiers would be following these trends with great interest.

French design by Wind Coop

The hybrid sailing ship Canopée
Credit: ariane.group

Cargo sailing vessel Anemos ("wind" in Greek)
Credit: Ronan Gladu (TOWT)

Still some of the old school ships exist from the old days and in various conditions they roam the world. Still sailing are for example Sea Cloud as a passenger ship, Kaiwo Maru, Eagle and Sedov as sail training ships (STS), as a matter of fact many tall ships survive as these. The running costs are paid for by their Gov't for use to train seafaring cadets and they work as good will ambassadors sailing around the world. This is a great way of preserving seafaring heritage and knowledge, I'm ashamed my own country, Finland, does not do this anymore. The last Finnish sail training ship was Suomen Joutsen that is nowadays rotting off the dock in my hometown Turku.

s/v Sea Cloud II (built 1931)
Credit: seacloud.com

s/v Sedov approaching Sète, France (built 1921)
Credit: Christian Ferrer (wikipedia)

USCGC Eagle in New York (built 1936)
Credit: USCG (BBC)

Mostly the old ones that also survive are today sitting in various states as museums in port cities or functions as other kind of public venues. Like e.g. Pommern in Mariehamn, Finland; Passat in Travemunde, Germany; Viking in Gothenburg, Sweden as a hotel and Moshulu in Philadelphia, USA as a restaurant, just to name a few of the ex Erikson fleet still in existence today.

Suomen Joutsen in 1930's (built 1902 at St Nazaire, France)
Credit: trafiikki.fi

Suomen Joutsen in Turku, Finland, 2023
Credit: Marc Pingoud (shipspotting)

There are few outfits that run old schooners as commercial ventures and one good example is the Fairtransport operating the Avontuur, De Tukker, Hawila, Nordlys, Brigantes and Tres Hombres in cargo trade and some paying passengers cum crew scenario. Other outfits doing the same mostly tend to be one ship shows.

Avontuur under sail
Credit: Timbercoast

* * * * *

Then without further ado, lets give the word to the old salt, Alan Villiers. Below he opens up about the state of sail in 1932 that was really not good with only a handful of tall ships in the whole world left in operation, laid up or shipwrecked compared to the hundreds that had existed in his youth (Editor).

Deep-Sea Sail

By A. J. VILLIERS

Not only the glamor but also the actuality of sailing-ships are still with us

Saw a four-masted schooner towing out to sea on Saturday afternoon, from her anchorage in the shadow of the Statute of Liberty. She was setting her sails as she threaded her way through the in-coming and the anchored steamers; before she had passed the quarantine station she had dropped her tug. It was almost a shock to see sails spread from a deep-sea commercial vessel in New York harbor.

But there are still sailing-ships, square-rigged as well as fore-and-aft, competing for the sea carriage of the world's goods. Twenty of them, in this year of grace 1932, are sailing from Australian ports to the United Kingdom and Europe with cargoes of Antipodean grain. Four of them sail in the nitrate trade, to Chilean ports. A few carry guano on the Peruvian coast; until recently an-other still carried passengers in the North Atlantic trade. Twelve of them, through the summer months, carry firewood from northern Baltic ports to London and Hull. Four or five others transport logwood from the West Indies to Marseilles and Le Havre.

How is it that there are still so many sailing-ships? When ten per cent of the world's steamships are laid up for lack of freights, how may sailing-ships find employment? The answer simply is that wind is still the cheapest power available; and while the wind blows there always will be sailing-ships of some kind.

Primitive man, watching the effect of a leaf thrust into a piece of bark borne by a stream, first discovered the power of wind on water-borne objects. His discovery remained un-used, except in the roughest way, for many centuries. Men did not trust the sea. They learned to propel themselves with oars in floating objects, and for a thousand years and more the use of such sails as they had always was subservient to the oars. They did not trust sails, not under-standing them. They used them only when they had fair winds, and then not over-willingly, not wishing to be blown too far. Was there not a danger of being carried away and swept over the world's edge? Development and understanding were slow. It took two thousand years to develop the perfect sailing-ship such vessels as the beautiful American clippers, the Scots-built iron square-riggers, and then, early this century, those magnificent vessels of the German "P" Line, of Hamburg, which represented the climax of development in deep-water sail.

From the Middle Ages onwards until the Nineteenth Century, there was scant change in the design of ships and little real progress. Progress and change were always vigorously opposed, particularly by interested persons. Now and again a freak vessel arose; but ninety-nine per cent of the ships that floated were cask-like in appearance and sailed like crates. The sea was not connected with speed (and neither, indeed, was the land); if a ship floated and was manageable, that was all that was asked of her. Fat-jowled East India-men and bluff, high-sided men-of-war represented the best of maritime design. They were inefficient and slow, but staunch and perfectly seaworthy.

Then some one hit upon the amazing idea that a sharp-lined ship might be both seaworthy and fast an idea which was promptly scoffed at and ridiculed by all those persons who were satisfied with ships as they were. These representing about ninety-nine per cent of the maritime population, the clipper ship might have had a poor chance if it had not been brought to such a pitch of perfection in America while the other nations, sticking to the old ideas, were left standing still. Others soon followed the American idea, when its practicability and amazing performance were known. The sailing-ship now rapidly advanced, almost ship by ship, until it reached the very climax of perfection. First speed, and speed only; then speed coupled with safety in carrying passengers; then speed plus big cargo capacity and great endurance power in standing up to the great winds of the Roaring Forties for 6,000 miles at a stretch, and to beat around the Horn; capacity to hold 4,000 and 5,000 tons of cargo. So came those wonder-ships, the Germans Preussen and Potosi. Five-masted ship and five-masted barque respectively, they carried more than 5,000 tons of cargo each with crews of some two score men, and for many years made long hard voyages out to Chile and back again to Europe, deep-laden both ways, with the speed of average tramp steamers.

But the development was too late. The sailing-ship reached perfection when it was doomed. Steam, hated, scorned, despised, but steadily progressing; improved land transport; the Suez Canal - these dealt deadly blows at the ocean sailing-ship. For many years the die-hards ashore scoffed at steamers and would not send cargoes in them because they were afraid of contamination by the engine oil or the heat of the boilers; nor would they book passages in steamers because they feared the boilers might blow up. (They sometimes did.) They hated the engine vibration, the thudding of the screw, the mechanical feeling of it all.

But the steamer marched steadily on. Always new people are growing up, to take the places of those who are prejudiced. The steamer, last century, found supporters of its own just as the airplane has in this. Rail-roads across the continent killed the American clippers; it was of little use to boast of passages to 'Frisco in eighty days when the train could get you there in six. One by one all the better trades passed from the sailing-ship, and nation after nation gave them up. America was slow, and the development of her merchant marine suffered accordingly. When sail was supreme, America's own ships carried nearly ninety per cent of American goods. By 1870 the figure had dropped to 35.6 per cent. By 1910 it was a mere 8.7. Other nations had passed America with the development of their steamers; Americans turned more and more towards the land.

Then came the War, of course, which altered that.

Great Britain steadily gave up sailing-ships, from the middle 'Nineties onwards. Although the last was lost as recently as 1929 (when the four-masted barque Garthpool was wrecked on the Cape Verde Islands while outward bound to Australia to load wheat), by 1921 there were few British sailing-ships in commission. There probably would have been none, if it had not been for the War.

The big British sailing-ship lines were bankrupted, or changed to steam. Germans, Norwegians, Italians and Finns bought their ships. The Germans used them for training personnel for their steamships, and found them profitable trade in the carriage of heavy bulk cargoes from awkward, outlandish ports such as nitrates from waterless Chilean ports and nickel ore from New Caledonia. The Italians rigged them down into barques, cut the royal yards from such masts as they allowed to remain square, gave them names four yards long and ran them on nothing until they were fit to run no longer. The Finns and the Norwegians formed small one-ship companies and made a successful business of sail-owning. Often their small companies included some British capital. They carried small crews in the ships and paid scant wages; but they kept the old names and did not cut the ships down.

It was France which dealt the sailing-ships of other nations their fatal blow. When others had stopped building sailing-ships for deep-sea trade, the French suddenly decided to build a great fleet of them. At St. Nazaire principally, though also at other centres, they set about the production of of a mighty armada of barques, four-masted barques and full-rigged ships that was destined to drive other sailing-ships all but off the ocean. The Government subsidized the building, and continued to subsidize the ships when they put to sea. By act of Parliament they were paid a bounty according to the number of miles they sailed; they immediately made every endeavor, on their voyages, to cover as many miles as possible. A French sailing-ship, bound from South Wales to Portland, Oregon, with a cargo of coal, would clear for Hobart in Tasmania first. She would sail ostensibly for "Hobart for orders," although every other sailing-ship clearing the Welsh port at the same time knew where to go and required no "orders." Hobart, in the far south of Tasmania, was the farthest point at which the French ships could touch unless they felt like calling at the Bay of Whales. It was, for years, not at all uncommon to see twelve of them make Hobart in a week, though nations except those which should have been most interested, Great Britain and the United States.

Apart from these training-ships (there are now forty-two sail-training ships in the world, and none is either British or American), sail has fared poorly. That four-masted schooner which I chanced to see is one of the last of her class. Times are bad for schooners now, and ports are full of them. There is a port in Maine where twenty lie, and you may have your choice for $5,000. The bigger the schooner the cheaper she is. In Boston, in San Francisco Bay, in Puget Sound, along the Maine coast, the schooners and the barquentines lie, hopelessly tied up, waiting for something to be done with them. A few on the West Coast have been bought into the Hollywood Navy, and have been blown up or sunk to form a sequence for a comic film. No, the schooners have fared even worse than the square-rigged ships, and they would have fared badly if it had not been for the Finns.

At least, for one Finn. And he really is a Swede. His name is Gustaf Erikson, and he lives in Mariehamn in the Åland Islands - those beautiful Baltic islands which are under the Finnish flag but are Swedish in everything else. This Gustaf Erikson is a sailing-ship master himself. He began his career before the War, with one ship which was lost on her first voyage. Steadily he built up this is no story of a ship-owner waxing fat through the War, breaking up in the lean times afterwards. Gustaf Erikson made nothing out of the War; he laid the foundation of his fortunes afterwards, when in 1919 the amazingly fortunate four-masted barque Lawhill earned $150,000 profit for him on one cargo out of Buenos Aires. The Lawhill was built in 1892, and a man who sailed in her in 1903 told me he put a chipping-hammer through one of her plates then. Yet she is still afloat, still in commission, still a wonderful earning power in the Erikson fleet.

With that $150,000 Captain Erik-son built up his fleet. He acquired other square-riggers from the Finnish ports where their owners, seeing the continued shipping slump, soon tired of them. He bought from the British, the Norwegians, the Germans, big sailing-ship after big sailing-ship. No other owner on earth was following such a policy. They all thought that he was mad.

But he was not mad. He knew what he was doing; and today he owns almost all the big sailing-ships (apart from the training-ships) in the world. And he makes them pay.

This he manages principally because of these factors:

(1) He keeps the ships at hunting for cargoes; he does not lay them up in ports waiting for cargoes to come and hunt for them.

(2) He carries his own insurance risks, and allows for insurance out of his own balance-sheet.

(3) His crews are paid very little; many of them are boys who pay a premium for apprenticeship, which is returned to them as wages. The supply of boys willing to do this is inexhaustible.

(4) There is little depreciation, simply because he bought the ships at their lowest value (in most cases) and the capital invested in them can not greatly exceed their fair scrap value.

(5) There is no overhead. Captain Erikson is his own office.

(6) The ships are run in the most economical manner possible, consistent with proper safety.

(7) Finland, like Great Britain, is off the gold standard.

These are the important factors which permit Captain Erikson to run his sailing-ships without the use of red ink in his balance-sheet. It is a one-man show. No one else is interested. He has bought ships to add to the Line out of the profits his existing ships made; he did not borrow from banks. In years when there were no profits, he bought no ships. In 1929 he had eight ships in the Australian grain trade, and four others profitably employed. He then acquired the four-masted barques Melbourne, Viking, and Ponape. The next was a bad year; he bought no ships. Last year was good. He had twelve ships in the Australian grain trade. Their average freight for carrying wheat from Australia to England was $30,000 each. They spent $25,000 each to earn that freight. He bought the beautiful German four-masted barque Pamir, and sent her off to Australia to join the others.

In this year of grace 1932, twenty big sailing-ships are racing round Cape Horn with Australian grain, bound to Falmouth for orders. Fourteen of them are Captain Erikson's. Fourteen big sailing-ships! Ten of them are four-masted barques. It is a shock to most landsmen (and a good many sailors besides) to realize that there are as many as ten four-masted barques still in commission.

But these are all old ships. The youngest of them, the newly acquired Pamir, is twenty-six years old. Most of them are over forty and have sailed a hard road all their lives. Very soon some of them will have to be scrapped. Captain Erikson is over sixty; he has one son, who does not follow the same traditions. What will happen to the Line - to sailing-ships when he goes?

I should guess that ten years represent the maximum of life before the surviving sailing-ships - probably much less. Only the Australian grain trade now supports those which sail the deep water; if grain prices do not improve, the Australians will not be able to afford chartering even sailing-ships. They make one voyage annually, going out in ballast with sand and stones. There is nothing else to take. Australia has enough sand and stones of its own; but the ships must be ballasted to stand up against the winds.

The logwood business is declining; buyers ask such small lots now that it is increasingly difficult to scrape together sufficient for a full cargo. Steamers can take the small lots, and move on somewhere else to fill the rest of their holds with something else. But the sailing-ship can not afford to be towed around from loading port to loading port. She must load in one port, and sail with her cargo to another. Guano is a drug in the market, for the same reason that Chilean nitrate is a too easy manufacture of the artificial product, together with a general buying disinclination throughout the world. The Russians have all but smashed the Finnish and Swedish firewood business with England. No matter how low the Finns and Swedes may come with their prices, the Russians from Archangel and the Kara Sea will always go lower.

So the firewood barques lie at anchorage in Mariehamn now, in increasing numbers. The logwood barques are laid up in Danish and French ports. The "P" Line of nitrate flyers is being heavily cut down, with the loss of the ship Pinnas and the sale of the four-masted barques Parma and Pamir. Only four four-masted barques remain; unless the general German outlook improves, these will also go. The surviving Atlantic packet, the last of the square-rigged passenger carriers, lies derelict and forlorn beside a New Bedford wharf. Coriolanus is her name, and she is fifty-six years old. Famous as a record holder between the United Kingdom and Calcutta, now she lies a battered and broken wreck. Her fore topmast is gone, and her main top gallant mast is broken off short. Irish pennants hang untidily from such of her running rigging as is left; the wheel has been forced from its hub and the figure-head has been prized off with an axe. For ten years she has transported Cape Verde Islanders from Praia to the United States, but that trade is stopped. Sixteen months ago she came into New Bedford to go bankrupt. Her sails are used by a local coal merchant for protecting pavements while he delivers coal.

Such few schooners as there are are coasting. There are odd cargoes of coal for them to shift, and granite down from Maine. Even in fishing vessels, sails have been supplanted very largely by engines; the new fishing craft out of Gloucester have stumpy masts, big engine units and electric light.

It seems that sail will not live long now, in competitive transportation. But after ten years of unbroken shipping gloom, the old ships have done well to remain afloat at all. In training they will always be useful; Japan, Italy, Yugoslavia, Romania, Poland and France are either building or have recently launched new sail training-ships. Britain is considering a nation-wide scheme for going back to sail for training purposes, while the State of New York has scrapped its auxiliary sail training-ship and gone over to a big steamer. American boys want to go in sail. Not a week passes but I receive many letters from American boys and sometimes from girls as well - who wish to serve in any capacity in the Parma, in which I have an interest. On the average, I receive about twenty such letters a week. A boy from Milwaukee and a boy from Yale have already left for Australia, to take their chance of shipping in one of the grain-racing windjammers for the voyage to Europe. It is significant that often a boy who wishes to go to sea in sail does not wish to go in steam.

Sail still should have a place on the face of the waters, for there are many bulk cargoes which sailing-ships can transport as efficiently as steamships can, and given an approach to normal times, I do not think that deep-sea sail will die entirely.

But for the survivors - the twenty racing homeward around the Horn the turning of the tide must come soon.

Footnote: Unfortunately Coriolanus never got restored and she was broken up in 1935, 3 years after Alan Villiers review (Editor).

Coriolanus
Credit: Clyde Ships


No comments:

Post a Comment

Feel free to comment anything :)